Beginners Team wiki pages

[Matthew East]

Hi,

On Tue, Jun 10, 2008 at 7:40 AM, Connor Imes <rocket2dmn at aol.com> wrote:
> Matthew East wrote:
>> Hi Connor,
>>
>> On Tue, Jun 10, 2008 at 12:01 AM, Connor Imes <rocket2dmn at aol.com> wrote:
>>> On the topic of teams, the Ubuntu Forums Beginners Team has their wiki
>>> area at https://help.ubuntu.com/community/Beginners (primarily under /Team)
>>> This clearly conflicts with separation of Help and Wiki.  Though I did
>>> not establish this area on the Help wiki (its existence predates my
>>> involvement with that team), I have been its maintainer for a few months
>>> now and have done extensive work on it.  Since it is rather well
>>> established there, I propose leaving it, unless you feel strongly
>>> otherwise.  I just thought I should run that past you.
>>
>> I think that ideally the material under the "Team" subpage should also
>> be on wiki.ubuntu.com. If you are concerned that moving it would lead
>> to links breaking, there is a solution - you can use a redirect on the
>> old team page to point at the new page. Are there other reasons that
>> you could be uncomfortable with moving it?
>>
>> The Beginners' team isn't the only team that has their wikipages on
>> the help wiki, the same is true of the Wiki Team -
>> https://help.ubuntu.com/community/WikiTeam. We have talked in the past
>> about moving those pages, but we haven't yet got around to it. I will
>> try and get to that in the next few days.
>>
>
> My primary concern is that pages outside of the wiki have it, like on
> the forums, as well as people's bookmarks.  I know a redirect can take
> care of that, it's just a bit of a hassle.  It would also require us to
> go through and fix a lot of little things like links.  Right now I would
> rather focus efforts on getting the actual documentation pages up to
> speed rather than moving perfectly usable and fairly often used pages
> between the wikis.  I agree though, these pages are in the wrong place.
>  I will move them at a later time if it's not a thorn in anybody's side
> at the moment.

That's fine with me. On the subject of the documentation pages, what
do you think about integrating the documentation into the rest of the
material on the help wiki, rather than having a separate "Beginners"
section?

The reason I raise this is that our approach is generally that all our
pages should be suitable for new users of Ubuntu, in terms of
readability. In terms of structure, we always suggest that new pages
should only be created where pages on the same subject don't exist, so
that we can try and ensure that the wiki has a coherent structure, and
so that users can immediately see where to go when they are doing a
search for a particular subject.

I think that a great approach for the Beginners team would be to
integrate the material in their pages into the main body of the wiki,
and then helping to ensure that the whole wiki is suitable for
beginners by reviewing pages and generally testing the wiki
(searching, the index, etc) from the eyes of a new user.

Let me know what you think about this.

-- 
Matthew East
http://www.mdke.org
gnupg pub 1024D/0E6B06FF