[OT] Understanding Linux backup limitations
Young
tuxman at knology.net
Fri Sep 12 22:24:43 UTC 2008
Bart Silverstrim wrote:
> Brian McKee wrote:
>> On Fri, Sep 12, 2008 at 4:04 PM, Young <tuxman at knology.net> wrote:
>>> Oh, great guru, please hear my plea. :)
>>>
>>> I want to understand why a Linux partition must be unmounted before a
>>> cloned image can be created. I haven't been able to find anything yet; I
>>> guess I don't know the key word to search.
>>>
>>> I'd appreciate a lead to something that explains this limitation.
>>>
>>> First, I'd like to know if it's a kernel issue, or a file system issue.
>>> Then an explanation of why the problem exists.
>> I agree with Bart that the only issue is the darned file might change
>> while you're backing it up.
>> That's not a Linux thing, it's a computer thing.
>>
>> LVM can do 'snapshots' that helps overcome this. I think Windows
>> shadow copy is similar. ZFS has something too.
>
> For the OP, is there a specific situation you're investigating backing
> up for? Anything in particular you're looking for advice on? Or was it
> just curiosity?
>
Mostly curiosity, but I'd like to see a solution. It's a shame for Linux
that a Windows backup program can create an image backup of a booted
system, but Linux can't.
My concerns are really for the SOHO users. Larger companies have
multiple systems, and probably a sys admin.
Creating an image backup of a Linux install is a pain. And because of
that it doesn't get done as often as it should. Or people backup only
their home directory. I know, for myself, that it's stopped me from
trying out certain things because the risk/reward/pain/time ratios just
weren't good enough. It's slowing down the learning process for me, and
I'll never really move to Linux unless this gets fixed, because I know
I'll end up skipping a backup.
And, while image backups aren't the only type of backup needed, the rest
of the backup programs available aren't very friendly either.
I think SOHO users need a GUI backup program that can create an image
backup, and then be set to auto create incremental or differential
backups on top that. I'd pay for that.
Mark
More information about the ubuntu-users
mailing list