Why does Firestarter not start on boot?

Derek Broughton news at pointerstop.ca
Thu Sep 13 14:15:54 UTC 2007


Nik wrote:

> In article <o9olr4-vad.ln1 at pointerstop.ca>,
>    Derek Broughton <news at pointerstop.ca> wrote:
>> Nik wrote:
> 
>> > In article <46E2763A.3080108 at ntlworld.com>,
>> >    Graham Watkins <shellycat.gw at ntlworld.com> wrote:
>> >> I've added it to start up services but it doesn't make any difference.
>> > 
>> >> It worked OK with Dapper but now I've installed Feisty, I can only
>> >> start it manually which is a pain.
>> > 
>> >> Anybody else had this problem and managed to solve it?
>> > 
>> > Why would you want it to start at boot?
> 
>> Because you start services, that may listen to the net, on boot?
>> Actually, I agree with you in principle - it shouldn't actually start
>> from the boot scripts. A firewall should be restarted whenever a network
>> connection is made, which means you'd want a script in
>> /etc/network/if-pre-up.d/ (if possible) or .../if-up.d/, but it should
>> certainly start before you log in to X. -- derek
> 
> But firestarter isn't the firewall, it's just a gui front end to the real
> firewall which is iptables.

You could be right...  firestarter has never suited my needs (it _still_
doesn't recognize that many of us use two different interfaces to access
the Internet at different times), but many of the firewalls I _have_ used
run a script at startup, and/or if-up, under the name of the application
but actually issuing the iptables commands.  So I would expect something
similar of firestarter.
-- 
derek





More information about the ubuntu-users mailing list