Changes to wiki page Bugs/Importance

Jean-Baptiste Lallement jean-baptiste.lallement at ubuntu.com
Fri Dec 6 07:00:08 UTC 2013


Hi Alberto,

I noticed that you made important changes to the Bugs/Importance wiki 
page [1], important enough to not be done without discussion. If it has 
already been discussed somewhere, could you please point me to the 
discussion.

One of the most important change you made was to rename the page from 
'Bugs/Importance' to 'Bugs/Bug importance'. Furthermore there is no 
redirection from the previous version to this new page. The consequence 
is that there are now broken links on several other sections, this page 
is not found anymore by search engines with terms like 'ubuntu bugs 
importance' or even 'bug importance' and it adds no useful information 
since the word 'Bugs' was already on the URI. It also breaks consistency 
with other pages of the Bugs section named 'Bugs/<Category>' e.g 
Bugs/Status, ...

You moved the header that contains the link to the bugsquad knowledge 
base from the top to bottom. This is important information that must be 
on top because it gives reference to triaging material for some one who 
is not familiar with it and landed directly on this page.

You removed the introduction that explains what is importance and who 
can set it. The screenshot is a nice addition though. There are now 2 
bullet points toward the end of the page, but who reads it entirely?

Don't get me wrong, I really appreciate your contributions but I think 
this is an important change to a core page of the Bugsquad knowledge 
base that needs discussion beforehand. I'd suggest to revert this page 
to rev 33, (especially the renaming of the page) then discuss your changes.

Cheers,

[1] https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Bugs/Bug importance formerly 
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Bugs/Importance

-- 
Jean-Baptiste
irc: jibel



More information about the Ubuntu-quality mailing list