Seeking some advice

[Phill Whiteside]

Hi Greg,

After some questioning, this is the result...

(12:29:44) phillw: Hi folks, could some one please advise as to against
what this bug should be reported...http://pastebin.com/SRLnr5fB
(12:30:21) tjaalton: the kernel
(12:30:52) phillw: tjaalton: thanks!
(12:31:41) tjaalton: although
(12:32:04) tjaalton: what does "get live session working" mean
(12:32:06) tjaalton: ?
(12:32:46) phillw: it means that the tester has to insert nomode to get it
to run?
(12:32:58) phillw: In my distinctly amateur opinion I'd suspect
nvidia-graphics-drivers since it could well be fallout from the new X
stack.
(12:33:04) tjaalton: no
(12:33:11) tjaalton: you don't have that on a live-cd
(12:34:03) phillw: okies, so it is a kernel regression?
(12:34:17) tjaalton: phillw: not necessarily
(12:34:54) tjaalton: is there a boot splash? does X start but hang later?
(12:36:43) phillw: I'm surmising from the tester that he needs to alter the
boot sequence to get X to actually run. Once he knows where to file the
bug, he will be able to give more information. He's an experienced tester,
just unsure as to what to report this one against.
(12:37:04) tjaalton: ubuntu-bug xorg
(12:37:14) phillw: thanks.
(12:37:18) tjaalton: that's a good place to start..

When filing the bug, please do answer the question about the presence, or
lack, of the splash screen.

Thanks,

Phill.



On 20 August 2012 03:47, Greg Faith <gregfaith at gmail.com> wrote:

> Here is the situation.
>
> I am using a live persistent USB of the Lubuntu quantal desktop amd64
> 20120819 to
>
> run live and install test cases. Presently I using a Dell D620 and
> Lenovo T61p to do full
>
> hardware installs.  The Dell D620 boots up live with no problem, but
> the Lenovo with
>
> nvidia graphics requires me to set F6 "nomodeset" to get the Live
> session working.
>
> Now with all that said a week ago I did not have to set the
> "nomodeset" on the Lenovo
>
> to get the live session working.  It is not really a big problem for
> me as I have worked
>
> through the issue, but I can see where a new user with a Lenovo kit
> with nvidia graphic
>
> might have a difficult time.
>
> I guess I am wondering should a bug be filed against the kernel as it
> appear to be a
>
> regression?
>
> Greg nm_geo
>
> --
> Ubuntu-qa mailing list
> Ubuntu-qa at lists.ubuntu.com
> Modify settings or unsubscribe at:
> https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-qa
>
> --
> <https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-qa>
> https://wiki.ubuntu.com/phillw
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-quality/attachments/20120820/671babb8/attachment.html>