Brainstorm Guidelines

[Nicolas Deschildre]

Hi,

On Fri, Apr 11, 2008 at 8:04 AM, Saïvann <oxmosys at gmail.com> wrote:
> I often works in brainstorm to moderate ideas and set ideas as
>  duplicates and I believe that we should really give a particular
>  attention to this idea :
>
>  http://brainstorm.ubuntu.com/idea/5476/
>
>  There is actually no guidelines for brainstorm ideas, so we get ideas
>  for almost everything, and people does not know if what they do actually
>  helps or just pollutes brainstorm.
>
>  Example :
>
>  Should people open ideas about upstream projects that canonical can't fix?
>
>  Also, there is no guidelines to write a new idea, the result is sometime
>  very poor described ideas. The initial description of a idea is VERY
>  important and should not be modified once people started to vote. People
>  need to have relevant examples to be able to write complete and
>  "readable" ideas.
>
>  I'm ready to discuss and work on this.

Great!
I globally agree.
But I'm wondering at the implementation: How would you do that? The
current guidelines (link in the front page) seems not enough.
A quick brainstorm:
* A small summary on the idea submission page itself.
* A link in this page to a larger page, with good ideas sample, and
more verbose comments.
Thoughts?
Would you give a try to the guidelines texts?

Regards,
Nicolas

>
>  Thanks to the ubuntu-qa team for improving brainstorm!
>
>  Saïvann
>
>  --
>  Ubuntu-qa mailing list
>  Ubuntu-qa at lists.ubuntu.com
>  Modify settings or unsubscribe at: https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-qa
>