Pulseaudio dependency, if Debian can do it ...
david.henningsson at canonical.com
Fri Jun 24 17:08:40 UTC 2011
On 2011-06-24 13:26, rosea.grammostola wrote:
> On 06/24/2011 01:08 PM, rosea.grammostola wrote:
>> A group of (professional) Linuxaudio users prefer to have a system
>> without Pulseaudio. How nice Pulseaudio can be for 'consumer audio', it
>> can be a pain on a professional audio system.
Whenever you have such pains, please file a bug for it, preferrable with
a very concrete example. While I might not have time to fix everything,
I do want to work for making Pulseaudio less painful to use, in use
cases including professional audio systems.
>> That's why some people
>> prefer to stick with just ALSA and JACK. On most systems this is not a
>> problem at all, like Fedora and even on Debian, but on Ubuntu it is.
>> This raises the question why ubuntu-desktop has Pulseaudio integrated in
>> such a way that almost the whole desktop system seems to depend on it.
>> There isn't a good way to remove Pulseaudio from Ubuntu! This is very
>> ugly and not a good way to handle things in the Linux world.
As Daniel said, GNOME upstream has integrated Pulseaudio heavily. You
might have more success trying another variant (e g xubuntu to see if
removing Pulseaudio is easier there, or perhaps not even present, I
>> Why? If you can remove pulseaudio easily on Debian, why is it so
>> freaking hard on Ubuntu? What is the best place to report this major bug?
If you just want to stop Pulseaudio from running, that's simple:
If that gives worse user experience, compared to removing Pulseaudio in
Debian, let me know.
> Ah it looks I am not the only one who really is getting sick of this!
> Since the introduction of Pulseaudio in Ubuntu you guys (sound / desktop
> related devs) got plenty of feedback from the community, but you are
> doing still the worst job in the Linux world, even while Debian provides
> you with a good example! The PA main developer himself curses Ubuntu
> (ok.. it has been a while ..) Argggg!!!
That particular complaint has since long been sorted out, except
possibly for flat volumes, which is still turned off.
David Henningsson, Canonical Ltd.
More information about the Ubuntu-devel-discuss