A tricky situation in malone bug 60995
nicolas.alvarez at gmail.com
Sat Oct 20 23:10:37 UTC 2007
On 10/21/07, Martin Olsson <mnemo at minimum.se> wrote:
> Nicolas Alvarez wrote:
> > It's the wrong way to fix it. You can lose data by clicking enter
> > while a link is focused too, should we disable the enter key? The
> > right solution has been mentioned multiple times in multiple places:
> > prompt "Are you sure you want to change page and lose what you typed?"
> Yes, exactly. Nobody is arguing *for* data loss, clearly data loss
> should be avoided (but using another, more intelligent method).
> I would also like to point you to the follow repro steps:
> 1. surf to cnn.com
> 2. surf to google.com
> 3. enter search query "hello"
> 4. press the BACK button in the browser
> 5. press the FORWARD button in the browser
> Voilá your search query is still there intact: no data loss! Maybe this
> was a big problem in previous versions of Firefox but right now, the
> data loss argument is running very short.
I agree the data loss argument is running short. And I agree with some
comments on bugzilla: if data loss was really a problem, why the
change doesn't affect Windows too? Are *nix users more prone to lose
data? I don't think so :)
By the way, keeping form data after going back and forward depends on
caching headers sent by the page, or so I heard. I can confirm it
doesn't always keep it. And I have also seen cases where I really
didn't expect it to keep it but luckily it did (like on some forums'
"Quick reply" feature, where the text box is hidden, and shown by
More information about the Ubuntu-devel-discuss