[ubuntu-art] [Breathe] Daniel's edits review

[dani]

El mar, 01-09-2009 a las 13:31 -0300, spg76 escribió:
> Hi.
> I finally got the time to make a review of Daniel's edits.
> https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Artwork/BreatheIconSet/Submissions?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=Breathe-Edit_0.10.tar.gz
> 
> First, I gotta say that I think that they look better that the old
> ones.
> Overall, I really like the icons with orange or green, but no so much
> the ones with yellow or blue which I found too muted.
> 
> The "actions" icons looks pretty good. I wouldn't make any change,
> except for the yellow or blue like I wrote before and for the envelope
> that it seems kind of dark to me.
> 
> In the "applications" icons there are several icons that I don't like
> for different reason (perspective, lack of details, I don't like the
> metaphor): accessories-character-map, accessories-dictionary,
> fusion-icon, gdm, preferences-desktop-wallpaper and
> preferences-desktop-theme. Also, the utilities-system-monitor and
> utilities-terminal icons, although can be improved, I don't think that
> they look better without the reflection.
> help-about, help-browser y system-software-update look a little muted
> (again the blue color).
> I love preferences-desktop-screensaver.
> 
> In the "categories" icons I don't notice much change but I'd say that
> the only thing that I don't like it's the color of
> applications-internet, preferences-system-network and system-help.
> 
> In the "devices" icons I noticed that the displays has changed and I
> think that they look much better that what I did, although I think
> that with a little work could look even better.
> 
> For the other sections I could say the same that I said before about
> the yellow and blue colors. Also I'm not sure about the folder (I have
> to use the set a little more).
> 
> Well, I think that's all.
> Take notice that this it's only my opinion and, of course, I'm open to
> hear everyone else's.
> That being said, I must add that Daniel did a fantastic job reviewing
> the icons and improving most of them. Gracias, Daniel.
> 
> Once we resolved what to do with this review, I will try to be back on
> track making new icons and reviewing my old ones to improve them and
> making them more consistent (colors, perspective, etc.).
> Sorry that this take me so long.
> Regards.
> -- 
> Seba (AKA spg76)
> http://www.ubuntu-ar.org

Thanks Sebastian, You and Cory have to send me the icons that will be
used and are discarded so i can review again and talk about it with
yours.

branch need update

Daniel.P