rejecting skype-translations

Adam Conrad adconrad at ubuntu.com
Sun Jul 13 07:39:18 UTC 2014


On Sat, Jul 12, 2014 at 10:25:12PM +0200, Gunnar Hjalmarsson wrote:
> 
> It should be noted that the package you rejected was uploaded against
> the universe component. If the translation files would prove not to be
> exempt from the Skype license, multiverse would be an option, wouldn't it?

The universe/multiverse split is about freedoms offered.  Both still
need to be distributable, however.  If the translations are considered
a derived work of Skype itself (and it's hard to argue with that point
of view, given not only that their only purpose is to be used with
Skype, but that they're also literally derived from the strings in
Skype itself), then the only people who can give you a valid license
to distribute are Microsoft.

Without that explicit license, any distribution would be a copyright
violation, component wouldn't matter.  With that license, then the
component depends on the license MS grants for translations, of
course.

... Adam



More information about the ubuntu-archive mailing list