Andrea MOTU Application

[Andrea Veri]

Scott Kitterman ha scritto:
> On Friday 13 July 2007 23:26, Gauvain Pocentek wrote:
>   
>> Stefan Potyra wrote:
>>     
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> Am Montag 02 Juli 2007 23:13:57 schrieb Lionel Porcheron:
>>>
>>> thanks Lionel for stepping in.
>>>
>>>       
>>>> For getting everybody happy, I proposed him to continue working with
>>>> MOTU tasks these days, and show us how excellent he can be :-). He was
>>>> fine with that and started to do some merge / sync request as I am
>>>> writing this mail. Thanks for that Andrea!
>>>>
>>>> So let's see the result in a few days!
>>>>         
>>> Andrea, first of all thank you very much for your steady interest in
>>> ubuntu and your contributions so far!
>>> Would it be OK for you, if we defer your application (or rather defer
>>> voting on your application) for one week?
>>>       
>> Could we have some feedback from the sponsors?
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Gauvain
>>     
>
> I've sponsored two things in this period and both of them were good, but not 
> ready for upload. 

you sponsored me :

1) https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/exaile/+bug/125070
2) https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/drpython/+bug/123614

a sync acked, and a merge uploaded at first debdiff, so why do you say 
"not ready for upload" if you definitely uploaded them?



>  I think Andrea is making valuable contributions and should 
> continue working towards being a MOTU, but in the small sample I saw, I don't 
> think the quality level is there for unsupervised uploading yet.  
>
>   

How you can define my quality level after checking my work on 2 packages 
(both of them were good, as I stated before)?
I see from my sponsors comments (like alexander sack) that my technical 
skills are good, and uploads in debian can confirm that too.


> I'm particularly concerned that there was sloppiness at a time when he's been 
> told to be on his best behavior.  
>
> -1
>
>   

sloppiness? if you want me to link the uploads I did this week, I'm 
here. And anyway I really don't understand how you can give me a -1 if 
both the packages you uploaded me were good.


> Please don't give up, just keep working on better consistency and working with 
> the other members of the community.
>
>   


I do it every day, thanks for the hint anyway.



> Scott K
>
>   


-- 
--
Andrea Veri
Email: bluekuja at ubuntu.com
Email: bluekuja at ubuntu-it.org (Contact for Ubuntu Italy)
Email: bluekuja at edubuntu.org (Contact for Edubuntu related stuff)