[OT rude or not, a different opinion] -Re: Beta 8.10 released

Thorny thorntreehome at gmail.com
Sat Oct 11 17:14:08 BST 2008


On Sat, 11 Oct 2008 13:23:57 +0100, Ignazio Palmisano wrote:

> I have to disagree with this argument: no one knows in detail what's in
> somebody's else head, and it's not up to the listener to ask for
> clarifications for every communication, it's up to the speaker to try to
> convey as much information as possible, so that the meaning of what's
> said is as unambiguous as possible. Wherever there is a hole in the
> communication, there is the possibility of misunderstanding, and what
> people do is fill up the holes with what *seems* most appropriate. As
> many have already said, email is a poor way to express feelings
> accompanying words, unless one tries really hard, which usually means
> very long emails.
> 
> 
I generally agree with what you said for normal communication. However, in
a place where people come to help and be helped, I think it is incumbent
on the helper (who has chosen that role, no one is forced to respond) to
make a considerable effort to understand and support a poster who might
have trouble expressing any part of the communication. In theory, those
with the best command of the language could be in a position to better
comprehend the nuances of that language and be aware of what might be
attributable to their own emotions . Specifically, this list is about an
operating system that is part of a group that desires to be welcoming and
supportive. I think I even read that somewhere in a mission statement
about Ubuntu but I don't have any link to cite. I interpret that as 'bend
over backward'(make the effort) to try and help, spend the time writing
those long emails and endeavor to make people feel welcome. YMMV. I can
do it for a while, but I too will quit replying to someone who, over time,
continues to be rude or trolls. 

I know your email wasn't threaded to my reply but you and I probably
approach things differently, even in person (meatspace) I would tend to
ask if someone is meaning to be rude or if I misunderstood what they said.
Of course, in meatspace, things do tend to play out a bit differently than
cyberspace. Posters who think they haven't been treated fairly tend to
just disappear and we may not get another chance to help them with Kubuntu.




More information about the kubuntu-users mailing list