Server booting problems

[compdoc]

> I have a drive where all those values are WAY more than zero


In Disk Utility gui, the column named VALUE is the one to watch. If using
the command smartctl, the column named RAW_VALUE is the one that matters. 

If you truly have reallocated sectors, (or the others I mentioned) you data
is already damaged and if you continue to use the drive more data will be
damaged.