What's best and easiest to check sync result ?

[SYNass IT Ubuntu / Linux]

On Tue, 2008-06-10 at 09:26 -0500, Paul Johnson wrote:
> On Mon, Jun 9, 2008 at 9:22 PM, SYNass IT Ubuntu / Linux
> <i-ubux at synass.net> wrote:
> > Hello Ubuntuans,
> > Recently we discussed rsync quite intensively ! ;-)
> > Since I was experimenting with it was very interesting to hear and
> > learn !! ;-))
> >
> > I already have done some "sync's" from my HDD to an external HDD quite
> > sucessfully and
> > I only have some questions how to check and control the result best and
> > easiest.
> >
> > My rsync closes with this statement:
> > sent 7565493096 bytes  received 1457080 bytes  819865.67 bytes/sec
> > total size is 7557361145  speedup is 1.00
> >
> > and properties shows following for:
> > Source: 4054 files / 6GB
> > Target: 4054 files / 6GB
> >
> > So, Source and Target, show identical values ! ;-)
> > Why is rsync's closing statement showing a difference ? :-|
> >
> > How can / does one check exactly these difference ???
> > Well, there are diff or Meld but ways to extensive and
> > very difficult to discover the difference and its reasons,
> > i.e. their files ??
> >
> > Is there a better solution available ?
> >
> > TIA for your advice and guidance,
> > cheers, svobi
> >
> >
> >
> > PS - My command:
> > rsync -av --progress /source /target
> >
> 
> Please note that rsync does not give a "speedup" with local copies.
> WHen it copies a file, it copies the whole file.  The selective
> copying of portions of files is only done on network transfers.
> 
> To check to see if 2 directories are the same, sometimes I do
> 
> rsync -ravn  /source /target
> 
> that will report back files that have different ownership, sizes,
> modification times, and/or checksums, depending on your options.  If
> you need to compare across 2 file systems, say ext2 to MSDOS, then you
> need to add an option --size-only so that it doesn't get distracted by
> the ownership.
> 
> On a local comparison, you can do this to see if 2 drives are the same:
> 
> diff -r /source /target
> 
> That should tell you exactly which items differ. (I just got curious
> how it compares. See:
> http://www.network-theory.co.uk/docs/diff/Binary.html. It says GNU cmp
> can report byte-by-byte differences among binary files).   It doesn't
> tell how they are different, it just reports "binary files differ"
> I'm new to Ubuntu, but I notice it also has tools "dirdiff" for
> comparing directories and "rdiff", a binary diff tool. dirdiff looks
> like fun, I've just installed it to see what it does.
> 
> If you are using target as a backup, I'd suggest you consider this
> tool "rdiff-backup".  I notice it is in the Ubuntu repositories.  It
> uses the rsync "copy only the changed part" power, even on a local
> system.  The first backup copies the entire file, but then on the
> following ones, it only saves the "changed part", and it layers those
> things so that, in the future, you can restore "that file from 14 days
> ago" or such.  Its quite impressive.
> 
> 
> > An extra question for parameter "Backup":
> > How and when does one need this being set !
> > Only at the first time to get a full set ??
> >
> > The following link shows a dsicussion about sync's options:
> > http://linuxgazette.net/147/misc/lg/rsync_options.html
> >
> > Unfortunately "Backup" isn't mentioned. ;-(
> >
> > Once more TIA for your help. ;-)


Hi Paul, 
Bart, Derek and Thilo
Thanks a lot for your interesting feedback and additional thoughts and
comments !

@Paul: Thanks for your efforts to explain to me !
I will have to print your suggestion/s and will try when 
the external (USB) HDD is connected next time !!

@ Bart: Well, a speedup isn't sought !
Top security / qualitiy is wanted !!

@Thilo: The Backup isn't zipped !
Rsynced is my home: /home/svobi !!


My present experimenting with rsync has to goals:

1) I want an easy and secure backup of all my personal data to this
external unit to 
have my data saved correctly and completely for restoring after my new
setup with 8.04 LTS !

2) This external HDD unit supports TCP/IP and USB !!
With my present rsync experiments I am learnign / trying to get data to
and back from the unit if connected with TCP/IP or USB however it is
hooked.

2a) Connected with USB it acts as Workstation support ! 

2b) Connected with TCP/IP it shall / will act as a NW Datapool !? 

2c) Unfortunately the unit does not support NSF but FTP and Samba !?


Since I only have very little experience in NW and technology 
I have to experiment and learn a lot:

Thanks for your appreciated support ! ;-)

Cheers, svobi