[ubuntu-studio-devel] [Blueprint ubuntustudio-video-x] ubuntustudio-video X

[WMID]

Jimm can you said me the name of this Swedish film maker who's latest
project are entirely done in Kdenlive, and the web page, or the youtube
channel

2015-05-11 7:32 GMT-05:00 Jimmy Sjölund <jimmy at sjolund.se>:

> On Mon, May 11, 2015 at 11:51 AM, Set Hallstrom <sakrecoer at gmail.com>
> wrote:
>
>> Hi!
>> On 2015-05-11 10:25, Jimmy Sjölund wrote:
>> > Blueprint changed by Jimmy Sjölund:
>> >
>> > Whiteboard set to:
>> > - Investige implication of Kdenlive becoming official KDE application
>> > and future development, impact of kde libraries etc.: TODO
>> >
>>
>> This is an interesting question! At the moment, there are 4 choices for
>> video editing:
>> - ptivi,
>> - openshot
>> - kdenlive,
>> - blender
>>
>> On a personal note, i have to confess that ptivi and openshot have given
>> me nothing but frustrations. They are the reason i installed kdenlive
>> back when it was not included in ubuntustudio. I also believe kdenlive
>> is the only reason i have kde libraires.
>>
>> While i must say Kdenlive is a great tool, Blender VSE has become
>> amazingly powerful. So much that i had almost forgotten about kdenlive
>> all together...
>>
>>
> The reason I put it up there is to check if it will affect Ubuntu Studio
> or not. It could be that it will continue to work just as before, but it
> raised some questions when I read Kdenlive's latest updates:
> -----------------------------------
> We stick to KDE Applications release schedule, which means one bugfix
> release every month, one feature improved version every 4 months.
>
> Since we are now based on Qt5/KF5, you NEED KDE Frameworks 5 to run
> Kdenlive.
>
> You will have to run a recent distribution offering KF5, this may be
> problematic at the beginning (you can stick to 0.9.10)...
> -----------------------------------
> So it could be that 0.9.10 would be that last version for Ubuntu Studio,
> or not.
>
> I have tried several video editors over the year and they all have their
> advantages and disadvantages. PiTiVi and openshot I would say are in the
> same category, easy to do home videos but not suitable for any medium or
> advanced editing. Making a amateur home music video with more than one
> video and one audio file is IMHO a mess.
> Kdenlive is quite powerful, but not the best GUI. This might have changed
> with the latest version though. You can with some work do a lot but it more
> often require google skills and reading forums to understand how to do it.
> Not click-and-drag like in Mac or Windows environments.
> Blender, to me, is more of a 3D application and not really a video editor
> even though you would be able to do a music video in Blender. I think it's
> a big step for someone new to linux to give them an advance 3D application,
> here go do some videos!
>
> So far Kdenlive have been the least worst choice. I know a Swedish film
> maker who's latest project are entirely done in Kdenlive.
>
> Then there is Lightworks and Cinelerra which are on the advanced side.
> They have a bit of more tricky licensing, but I haven't studied them in
> detail.
>
> /Jimmy
>
> --
> ubuntu-studio-devel mailing list
> ubuntu-studio-devel at lists.ubuntu.com
> Modify settings or unsubscribe at:
> https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-studio-devel
>
>


-- 
Washington Indacochea Delgado
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-studio-devel/attachments/20150511/2b611470/attachment.html>