[Bug 1809932] Re: [SRU] [Bionic] gparted fails to shrink LVM PV with lvm2 >= 2.02.172

[Thomas Ward]

*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 1779292 ***
    https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1779292

** Changed in: gparted (Ubuntu)
       Status: New => Fix Released

** This bug has been marked a duplicate of bug 1779292
   GParted fails to shrink an LVM PV with lvm2 >= 2.02.171

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Sponsors Team, which is subscribed to the bug report.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1809932

Title:
  [SRU] [Bionic] gparted fails to shrink LVM PV with lvm2 >= 2.02.172

Status in gparted package in Ubuntu:
  Fix Released
Status in gparted source package in Bionic:
  New

Bug description:
  [Impact]

  GParted in Bionic uses LVM2 versions >= 2.02.172.  Because of this
  higher LVM version, it is impacted by the same issue as Bug #1779292 -
  the confirmation prompt added to the pvresize system makes all LVM2
  resize operations involving shrinking (and possibly expanding) LVM
  Physical Volumes fail because of unexpected output.

  As such, gparted on Bionic cannot be used to resize LVM physical
  partitions.

  This was fixed by syncing a newer version from Debian in Cosmic
  series, however still impacts the Bionic series.  If we intend to have
  Bionic as an LTS (as we do), then we need to patch this.

  The attached patch is identical to the patch on Bug #1779292, and is
  adapted from upstream changes to

  
  [Test Case]

  (0) Prerequisites: A drive with an LVM2 partition on it for the PV,
  and a VG with LVs within that do NOT take up the entirety of the LVM2
  partition (so for a 100GB LVM PV, consume anything less than that so
  we can resize the PV; you may resize LVs for this if you need to).

  With existing software versions:

  (1) Boot up a LiveCD/LiveUSB, open `gparted` on it.

  (2) Attempt to resize with current gparted on the repos / image.

  Current Result: ERROR due to unexpected message.

  With patched version:

  (1) Boot up LiveCD/LiveUSB

  (2) Install PPA version of `gparted` (or from -proposed if this has
  landed in proposed for verification)

  (3) Attempt to shrink PV to make some free space (provided that step 0
  is met).

  Expected Result: SUCCESS

  
  [Regression Potential] 

  Messing with gparted could lead to other problems,  This is always a
  risk.  The potential for regression on this is low, however, provided
  that the patch is applied carefully.

  The patch literally only changes the the arguments passed to pvresize
  of --yes to 'confirm' that we want to do the changes.  This change is
  already applied in upstream versions later than that in Bionic,
  therefore the regression risk of this is low.

  
  [Other Info]
   
  This was test-built and *actively tested* in a PPA with the upstream patch (or rather, the patch listed in #1779292).  I got the upstream patch for the debdiff from upstream's master repository for the patch included in the debdiff.  (https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gparted/commit/5892b72890748c1d3e96bd7e25800c8aab351025)

  Note that the PPA was tested from a LiveUSB of 18.04.1(.0) and was
  used on a production system to resize the PV of my 18.04 laptop so I
  could put a new partition with Clonezilla Live-HDD version on it.  It
  works if you wish to test it, even though it uses the patch from Bug
  #1779292 and not a patch pulled directly from upstream's master
  branches/repos.


  [Original Description]

  This is technically a duplicate of #1779292, however that only affects
  Cosmic.

  This issue now impacts Bionic as well, because we are on LVM2 >=
  2.02.171.

  There appears to be a patch on #1779292 that can be used to fix this
  issue, perhaps this can be applied as an SRU to Bionic for GParted?
  It is otherwise impossible to resize a LVM PV with GParted on 18.04.

  (Importance set to High to match the other bug's importance).

  All other details and test cases in the other bug are identical.  It
  was only fixed in Cosmic, and not addressed in Bionic.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gparted/+bug/1809932/+subscriptions