Ubuntu server GUI
nvalcarcel at ubuntu-pe.org
Sat Jun 28 01:15:00 BST 2008
Well i was thinking on doing it using MVO model so it would be easy to
add more GUI's, so if you want to do it i'm ok with that, also i'm
more a backend man than a GUI one, so if you want to write the GUI and
the i add the backend i will be happy with the idea so we can load
balance an i can concentrate my efforts on writing the backend.
On Fri, Jun 27, 2008 at 9:50 AM, Matthew D Barley <matt.barley at duke.edu> wrote:
> I really like the idea. I am one of those individuals that you refer to
> who are somewhat new to the Ubuntu/Linux environment and a GUI interface
> on the server-end sounds like a fantastic idea.
>> On Fri, 2008-06-27 at 15:08 +0200, JAWUD wrote:
>>> Just my thoughts on ubuntu server GUI.
>>> English is not my native language so I apologize for grammar mistakes.
>>> Windows server system is very popular and I think it is because of the GUI it
>>> has. In my opinion a user should be able to configure a server without the cli.
>>> GUIs have some big advantage over the cli, it's easier to learn, more users are
>>> comfortable with it and it just looks better. There is also a huge demand for a
>>> good gui, see all the brainstorm ideas.
>>> But a server without CLI is also not nice. A lot of Linux sysadmins are used to
>>> it and some things are very hard to do with GUIs. So the perfect server os
>>> should provide the user with a nice clean GUI but without disrupting the usual
>>> Building a GUI doesn't automatically mean that the problem is solved. Developing
>>> a bad GUI isn't that difficult. The GUI needs a lot of usability testing. I also
>>> believe that the GUI shouldn't be developed with the current situation in mind.
>>> Systems like webmin provide a GUI for a lot of server software, but it isn't
>>> The target group of a GUI are people with less Linux experience and who wants a
>>> stable and secure server. People who knows the cli are probable not interested
>>> in the GUI. People with large deployments are also not interested in a GUI. They
>>> want control over all the details.
>>> Server GUI options:
>>> There are several options for a GUI. First one is to run X/gnome and make a GUI
>>> for the server. Remote server management can be done with VNC. This is the
>>> windows way of server management. Running X/gnome takes a lot of resources and
>>> VNC is not so fast. So this is not a nice option.
>>> Another option is to run a web server and make a web interface. As far as I know
>>> this is the current vision of the ubuntu server team (ebox). Running a web
>>> server also takes some resources. Another disadvantage is that web interfaces
>>> are not as nice and rich as QT/GTK apps. The real time graphs like system
>>> monitor are not possible with html/css etc.
>>> The third option is to create a curses GUI. The advantages are that it doesn't
>>> take a lot of resources, doesn't need some external services like a web server
>>> and it is accessible via SSH. Some huge disadvantage is that it looks horrible.
>>> How things looks are also important on the server. Server admin are also humans
>>> just like desktop users.
>>> The last option is to make a remote GUI system. Here's a example: a user
>>> installs the "Ubuntu Server Console" program on his desktop. It's a GTK or QT
>>> app which can be used to connect to a supported ubuntu server via ssh so it can
>>> be configured. In my opinion this is the best option. It has a nice and rich GUI
>>> and there is no web server or X/gnome. It's comparable with Rapache.
>>> Maybe I can do a small usability test to figure out what people think of cli,
>>> curses or remote gtk. I can also create a ubuntuforum poll to get peoples
>>> All the interfaces are just different front ends. So I think ubuntu needs a
>>> configuration abstraction layer. Something like Augeas. Augeas can become the
>>> back end and then it's easier to build different GUIs. Augeas intend to cover
>>> all commonly used configuration files and it is still possible to edit the
>>> config files manual.
>>> Work together?
>>> There are several people working on some gui option. Why not create one big
>>> project, define some goals, create a roadmap and start working. These people
>>> might be interested in working together..
>>> Nxvl – packaging augeas for ubuntu and want to build a cursus gui
>>> Rapache – working on a remote apacke gui tool
>>> Satega – working on ubuntu home server
>>> Someone else??
>>> As far as I know all these people are on this mailing list. Together we can do
>>> nice things and I'm interested in your opinion about this. Especially in
>>> creating a "Ubuntu Server Console".
>>> - JAWUD
> Kindest regards,
> OIT Help Desk
> Duke University
> ubuntu-server mailing list
> ubuntu-server at lists.ubuntu.com
> More info: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ServerTeam
More information about the ubuntu-server