[Bug 1416009] Re: Make squid package in 14.04 multithread supported

[Robie Basak]

Thank you for taking the time to report this bug and helping to make
Ubuntu better.

I understand that you have a single use case here, and that you expect this to just work on 14.04. From the point of view of fixing it though, there are a few different changes required, which need to be treated differently.
These are:

1) Create /var/run/squid3 automatically.
2) Drop -N from being specified to squid.
3) Apply change 1) as an update to 14.04.
4) Apply change 2) as an update to 14.04.

1) and 2) would apply to the development release and thus the next LTS.
3) and 4) would apply the change to existing 14.04 users. Our policies
require us to do 1) before 3), and 2) before 4), to avoid users
experiencing a regression when upgrading to a new release in the future.

It also seems to me that you can do all of this on a system by editing
/etc/init/squid3. This is a "conffile" and changing it manually is
permitted - the packaging system will endeavour to leave any
customisation to this file intact. So an available workaround to all of
this is to manually correct /etc/init/squid3.

So considering each necessary step individually:

For 1) and 2), note that we're hoping to switch to systemd this cycle,
so the upstart script will no longer be relevant. I don't see a systemd
unit defined, so it will fall back to the init.d script. This makes 1)
and 2) quite different to 3) and 4): the former needs to be fixed in
/etc/init.d, and the latter in /etc/init.

1) I don't see /var/run/squid3 being created in the init.d script, so it
looks like we'll need to fix this in Vivid.

2) It doesn't look like -N is being used, so this shouldn't be a problem
in Vivid.

3) If this is required, it is a bug that the upstart script doesn't do
this before starting squid. It would be reasonable to fix this in an
update to 14.04, but is it worth it? It's for a non-default use case,
and you'll need to apply a workaround for 4) anyway (see below). On the
other hand, if it turns out that many people are affected by this, it
would be valid to issue an update to 14.04 for this.

4) I don't think we can change this in an update to 14.04. It would
change behaviour of squid to every existing 14.04 user, and unless
further analysis suggests otherwise, I think this would present too big
a regression risk to existing users. So I think you will need to apply
the workaround as above.

So in conclusion:

I think we should fix 1) in Vivid. 2) doesn't appear to be required. 3)
is reasonable to fix in an update to 14.04, but I'm not sure it's worth
it given that users will need to apply a workaround anyway, so unless an
objection is made, I propose not to do it. For 4), the only reasonable
option is for 14.04 users to apply the workaround.

I'll leave this bug open to track 1).

** Changed in: squid (Ubuntu)
       Status: New => Triaged

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Server Team, which is subscribed to squid in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1416009

Title:
  Make squid package in 14.04 multithread supported

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/squid/+bug/1416009/+subscriptions