remove this game your repository it calls "over god"

[Stefan Ebner]

vido wrote:
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Stefan Ebner on behalf of Stefan Ebner
> Sent: Sun 6/28/2009 12:31 AM
> To: vido
> Cc: ubuntu-motu at lists.ubuntu.com
> Subject: Re: remove this game your repository it calls "over god"
>
> vido wrote:
> >
> > i ask you to remove this game from your repository it calls "over god"
> > the package name calls "over god " but when you enter the game you
> > will find
> > the word "over god" written like his "over God".
> > and the word god can go with lot of  meanings  but when we are talking
> > about
> > the word God
> > it can only mean our God the creator of every thing and the God of
> > every thing
> > so how come to any thing  can be over our God
> > and the name of the package  also not appropriate
> > you may look to this situation as a freedom of speech
> > but this point of view is wrong
> > coz if we think that author can do that coz he didn`t Believe in God
> > then i`m Believer
> > so i can do a game insult bozh in it or musslims can do it to christian
> > or christian  can do it to jews
> > and then what?
> > every team insult the name of the other team  God
> > is that your idea of Peace between humans
> > man that`s not right i again ask  you  to remove it from your  
> repository
> > its just a stupid game and it will cost you nothing to remove it
> > if you want Depends freedom of speech and expressing views freely do
> > it with
> > respect to other People Beliefs , Religions and Feelings
> > that is all for now
> >
> >
> >
>
> Hi!
>
> You know that I don't believe in god as we spoke about it on freenode.
> First I have to say that I don't have anything against any religion
> (except the violent ones).
>
> I don't know in what religion you participate (christianity?) but here
> are my thoughts:
>
> In Christianity the first commandment is: "I am the Lord your God", the
> German version
> would be something like: "Don't use the name of god carelessly".
> This would be the point you are complaining about *but* we follow the
> rules of the
> state and not the rules of the ten commandments. My government only says
> that you are not allowed to insult other religions. Speaking about or
> using the word
> god is not an insult, but something like "Your God s*cks" ...
> This is not the case so I think removing this game (I tested it and my
> personal opinion is
> that I don't like it as you said it's crap which is rude anyways) is
> censorship and I'm
> totally against it.
>


> Stefan
> english is not my 1st lang
> so
> i didn`t understand what you ment by
>
I'm trying to clarify.
>
>
> """god is not an insult, but something like "Your God s*cks"""
>

I wrote:
"speaking about or using the word god is not an insult,
but something like "Your God s*cks" which means that
since we are following the rules of the state it is not
a crime or something bad to use the word "God" like
in this game.

If the name of the game would be "F*ck God"
I'm sure the situation would be different.

>
> and  can i under stand from
>
> """This is not the case so I think removing this game (I tested it and my
> personal opinion is
> that I don't like it as you said it's crap which is rude anyways) is
> censorship and I'm
> totally against it.."""
>
> that you agree to delete this game from your repository
>

*No!*
You wrote that this game is crap so I tried it out
and as I said I'm of the opinion that I don't like it
but this is *not a reason* to remove it from the archive.

I said: Removing this game is censorship and I'm totally
against it -> I'm totally *against **removing* this game.
>
>
> i`m waiting your respond
>

PS.: It seems you just replied to me. For the future please CC
 the motu mailingslist