[ubuntu-mono] [Bug 785822] Re: Banshee does not remove selected song from playlist

[Erik S]

Still present in banshee 2.4.0 with Ubuntu 12.04:

But I found out, which song is deleted ;) Maybe this will help to fix
the issue:

When you add different songs, albums to a non-smart play list or to the
play-queue, and don't shuffle or sort by anything else than the Title ID
(the very left column), the selected song or songs will be removed
correctly. But(!) when you shuffle or sort Banshee won't delete a random
item from the list: It deletes the item, which was on this position on
the initial sorting.

Example:
1. Clear the play-queue
2. Add different songs to the queue with drag&drop
3. Open the queue (don't sort or shuffle) and select one songs and delete it (should work properly)
4. Select multiple songs (still not sorted or shuffled) and delete them (still works properly)
5. Now look on the (example:) 3rd item and memorize this item.
6. Shuffle or sort the list and make sure, your memorized item is NOT on the previous position.
7. Now select the 3rd (your initial) item and delete it
-> This shouldn't work, instead your memorized item should be removed. 

Can anyone prove me wrong or confirm my ideas?

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
CLI/Mono Uploaders, which is subscribed to banshee in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/785822

Title:
  Banshee does not remove selected song from playlist

Status in Banshee Music Player:
  Fix Released
Status in “banshee” package in Ubuntu:
  Triaged

Bug description:
  Binary package hint: banshee

  I have several playlists in Banshee (both static and smart).  Lately,
  I noticed that Banshee does not always remove the selected item from
  static playlist, instead it removes a random item. If you try to
  remove song that is playing, it always stays on the playlist and
  instead _ another_ song is removed. That to me is really unwanted
  behaviour.

  However, even if you are playing songs from playlist1, you sometimes
  cannot remove a songs from playlist2. And I mean the static playlists
  here where you add and remove items manually. I have not found clear
  logic on when the selected song can be removed. Only one case is
  clear: when you're playing songs in order (no shuffle), you can remove
  selected song after 4-5 songs have been played from begin to end after
  the one you want to remove. However, most often when you try to remove
  a song from static playlist, some song is removed -usually not the one
  you want.

  I am using 10.10 Ubuntu and Banshee 1.8.1.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/banshee/+bug/785822/+subscriptions