screencast file extension - ogv, not ogg

Kamil Páral ripper42 at gmail.com
Fri Dec 7 08:37:38 UTC 2007


Jeremy Visser napsal(a):
> On 05/12/2007, at 9:51 PM, Kamil Páral wrote:
>> Hello,
>> please notice that the default filename extension for videos in OGG
>> container should no longer be .ogg, but .ogv. Please read
>
> Interesting. It shouldn't cause any problems, no matter what the 
> extension, because GNOME uses heuristics to detect the correct 
> mime-type anyway.
Not in this sense, no. But it causes other problems:
https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=12890
It's simply not the preffered extension anymore :)

When media players are updated, there's gonna be some period where some 
not-aware players would not run automatically on .ogv videos (mainly in 
Windows, not checking the mime-type but extension) and some players 
would play only audio from .ogg videos according to changed extensions. 
It's sad but that's it. The solution is to update to comply with 
preffered extension as many players and as many videos as possible at once.

As ogg videos I have seen mainly screencasts and nothing more. So it's 
true that it's not really breaking the whole world, at least yet. That's 
why the change should happen asap and it's happening now.

I just wanted to inform you that your new screencasts should prefferably 
have the new standardized extension, not the old.





More information about the ubuntu-doc mailing list