Reply-to in Maillinglisten [was: Verzeichnis /etc/acpi/resume.d]

Martin Schmitz ubuntu at zangpo.org
Son Jun 17 18:03:41 BST 2007


Am 17.06.07 schrieb Matthias Houdek <linux at houdek.de>:
> Ein All-Reply schickt die Antwort an alle ("From", "Cc", "Reply-to", 
> Listenadresse).

Aha, da haben wir ja den Fehler. Die Adresse aus dem From hat da nix zu
suchen, wenn Reply-To gesetzt ist. Aus RFC2822:

   When a message is a reply to another message, the mailboxes of the
   authors of the original message (the mailboxes in the "From:" field)
   or mailboxes specified in the "Reply-To:" field (if it exists) MAY
   appear in the "To:" field of the reply since these would normally be
   the primary recipients of the reply.  If a reply is sent to a message
   that has destination fields, it is often desirable to send a copy of
   the reply to all of the recipients of the message, in addition to the
   author.  When such a reply is formed, addresses in the "To:" and
   "Cc:" fields of the original message MAY appear in the "Cc:" field of
   the reply, since these are normally secondary recipients of the
   reply.

> Damit verhält sich KMail durchaus normal.

Stimmt. Für MUAs ist es ziemlich normal, daß sie kaputt sind. ;-)

Martin