[Bug 179399] Re: bluetooth-properties crashed with signal 5 while adding HID device

[Robert Lange]

Further investigation indicates that the failure described in comments
25 and 26 is caused by a dbus timeout.  Dbus links bluetooth-properties,
bluetooth-applet, and other intermediary processes, and together, they
pair bluetooth devices and configure the system to use those devices.
When a remote procedure invocation over dbus fails to return after some
specified period of time, dbus times out and returns an error code.  The
crash occurs because bluetooth-properties assumes the call always
completes successfully, and does not check the error code; it therefore
passes an uninitialized variable to another function, which triggers the
crash.

Bug #230932 in bluez-gnome seems to be the most frequent reason for the
timeout.  In short, the bluetooth-applet user interface fails to inform
the user that he needs to re-enter the passkey on the bluetooth
keyboard.  If the user waits too long, because he does not know he needs
to do anything, then dbus will timeout, triggering the crash.

I stress that merely solving bug #230932 does not fix this bug.  Failure
to check error codes is always a bug, and it is both hard to find, and
easy to avoid in the first place.  Furthermore, it is possible that
bluetooth pairing will timeout for reasons other than the user not
responding quickly enough; we need to check the return code to protect
against those cases too.

After dbus times out and bluetooth-properties crashes, the bluetooth-
applet can still accept the passkey sequence and complete the bonding.
However, the keyboard is still unusable until the user re-opens
bluetooth-properties and manually re-attempts to pair the already-bonded
keyboard; this time, the process always seems to succeed, as the passkey
has already been accepted.  However, many users will have already given
up in frustration, assuming that bluetooth is broken.

Something needs to be done to prevent dbus from timing out.  Hopefully,
someone who understands dbus better can help.

-- 
bluetooth-properties crashed with signal 5 while adding HID device
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/179399
You received this bug notification because you are a member of
Bluetooth, which is subscribed to bluez-gnome in ubuntu.