[ubuntu-art] [Breathe] Additions to "Actions"

Cory K. coryisatm at ubuntu.com
Thu Mar 26 20:42:59 GMT 2009


Oliver Scholtz 1 wrote:
> Me again ... :) It's important to talk and impress some feelings looking
> around. :)
>
> System-shutdown ... seems to look finally totally acceptable - nice.
> This should work now.
>
> System-Search is not accepted by me. The microphone and differents Icons
> have the 45°-fall. Here I can't define the *°-fall. I will specific me
> more. The ocular is too small! The symbols like "+", "-" and "fit
> page"!!! won't have place in small sizes - so this loupe will be taken
> as default I see a problem with it. Another critic is the old-style of
> it. The rest of the icons are up to date and modern ... this style don't
> fits with the rest. For this reason I created quickly a new one ... :o
> Important: I don't say it's ugly ... it's only for the reason I wrote
> above. ;)
>   

> The symbols like "+", "-" and "fit page"!!! won't have place in small size...

This is a very valid *technical* reason you did not address before. One
I had not considered.

As for *style* I didn't see it as old or new. Didn't matter here. :) For
me, the choice came down to the fact that your submission was blurry by
comparison to the rest of the set.

However, any new submissions along with real-world/in use (screenshots
would work) evidence that the current loop is to small in the cases you
site will be greatly appreciated.

> Conclusion:
>
> Would be nice the *community* here votes their favourite, so we have two
> different kinds for system-search (old-style or modern) made. Would be
> really nice to know how the voting is. :)

Voting is crap. We put it up. Discuss. Move on. (but still open to
discussion later)


-Cory K.



More information about the ubuntu-art mailing list