[ubuntu-art] Expressing dislike

[Nemes Ioan Sorin]

Matthew you have right,

Good models are gears of the progress. Comparison is the mother of the 
progress.
Those discussions should not take consideration for not funded opinions. 
I think this is good because " ... " / this is not ok because " ... ".

Else ...words in the wind. Significant facts are being done by 
significant peoples. A significant people has funded positions. Always.

"This theme is too MAC'ish/XP'ish/***'ish" -> so what ? where's the point.

My other 20 cents

Matthew Nuzum wrote:
> On Dec 19, 2007 1:53 AM, [someone] wrote:
>
>     Looks nice indeed. But doesn't it look too much like MacOS?
>     (except for the color palett of course)
>
>
> I propose a new rule that anyone who says, "that theme looks too much 
> like [some other OS]..." must also back up their statement with an 
> objective comparison of the elements in question. I think it's being 
> tossed out as a generic criticism. I'm all for constructive criticism 
> and I'm certainly not opposed to people voicing their dislike for all 
> or part of a mockup, but its most helpful if the concerns are specific.
>
> Just my two cents.
> -- 
> Matthew Nuzum
> newz2000 on freenode