Chan Chung Hang Christopher
christopher.chan at bradbury.edu.hk
Wed Jun 10 14:45:57 BST 2009
> /me raises hand. But _please_ don't introduce another nonsense unit like
> KB - it is _kB_ with lower case k.
Haha, there is no set standard on that now is there? I mean, I see KG
and kg for example. Or KM and km.
>> Hands up those who want Ubuntu to wait till there is an operating
>> system standard like POSIX that declares convention dead and
>> standards are in vogue.
> Someone has to make the first move. And Linux is already moving in the
> right direction, the kernel uses binary prefixes for many years. Good
> luck if you want to make all (or even only all Unix-like) operating
> systems switch from bad habits to standards compliance. I'm not sure if
> POSIX is relevant for the desktop at all. It may be important for the
> command line to keep existing scripts working.
Why should not posix be relevant for the desktop too? Maybe it won't
cover everything on the desktop but at least having the command line
utilities reporting sizes of bytes in one particular form and meaning
would encourage desktop apps to follow suit and therefore not be a cause
Existing scripts? Ha! No, if you are going to do this, you will have to
blow everything out of the water. Existing documentation, scripts,
everything. Existing scripts will have to be fixed. If not, then forget
about the whole correct the units move.
> But your poll isn't really useful because you didn't ask the important
> question: Should desktop applications display file size in decimal or
> binary prefixes, i.e. should the application show "1013 MiB" or should
> it rather show "1062 MB"?
Ha! That, frankly, can be left up to the user's choice. If the user
likes base2 kibibytes fine. If the user likes base 10 kilobytes, that is
fine too. I don't care which one is used. All I care is that it be
consistent across all operating systems. I don't want to have to work
out whether they are using legacy KB or proper KB. (switching everything
to KiB looks very workable at the moment...no confusion but won't solve
the problem or worse, could lead to stagnation of correct the units and
maybe even introduce KB = KiB thinking)
More information about the sounder