need to unplug USB drive

Sylviane et Perry White spwhite at freesurf.ch
Mon Oct 29 17:33:46 GMT 2007


On Sunday 28 October 2007 15:45, Earl Violet wrote:
> --- Nigel Ridley <nigel at rmk.co.il> wrote:
> > Sylviane et Perry White wrote:
> > > Hi,
> > >
> > > If I plug in my "SanDisk" as user A, A becomes the owner.
> > > Then if I change session to user B, B cannot write to the
> >
> > "SanDisk"
> >
> > > I tried to su as user A (perry) and use chmod, but to no avail:
> > > I was able to decrease the permissions to 700 (that made the
> >
> > drive not
> >
> > > accessible at all for user B)
> > > But trying to increase the permission at 777 had no effect for
> >
> > user B and the
> >
> > > setting was back at 755 after su(ing) again to user A.
> > >
> > > I also explored the system settings  and got the access right
> >
> > bars ungreyed
> >
> > > (clickable) in the access-right tab of the properties for the
> >
> > disk ( and also
> >
> > > managed to have executable programs work directly from the drive)
> > > That was of no help because I could not make those permissions
> >
> > stick(y)
> >
> > > Had no luck on Google either.
> > >
> > >
> > > Solutions:
> > > 1) Pull out and plug in again the disk ("safely remove does not
> >
> > work here")
> >
> > > 	_simple but not elegant.
> > > 2) Change session to user A, "safely remove" and change again to
> >
> > user B.
> >
> > > 	_tedious, and does not work unless disk is physically removed.
> > > 3) su as A and use command lines to write.
> > > 	_my wife can't do that  ;-)
> > >
> > > 4)	***What do you suggest?***
> > >
> > > Thanks for pointers		Perry
> >
> > There is a similar problem with other auto-mounted media devices.
> > The same thing happens with a data CD or a digital camera (USB). My
> >
> > daughters' computer will sometimes have 2 active users (with one of
> > them
> > having inserted a data CD) and then I come along (and log into my
> > account) to do something with the cdrom and can't unmount it
> > because
> > there are already 2 users 'accessing' it. I try to eject/unmount it
> > but
> > get the 'Device in Use' message (or something similar) - so I
> > switch
> > users and try again only to get the same message. I have to log
> > everybody out except for one user then eject/unmount it.
> >
> > There must be a better way to manage auto-mounted media devices.
> >
> > Blessings,
> >
> > Nigel
>
> I have a similar problem with my USB stick.  
IMHO only to a certain extent.
> I can copy a file to it 
> but when it comes to loading it on another computer,
Do you mean you cannot read from the stick or copy  its files to the 2nd 
computer?
> I need to move  it as root and change the permissions.
The permissions of the stick or of the files within?
>
> Earl
>

Hi Earl,

I wouldn't be too surprised if you could solve your problem before Nigel or I.
As for Nigel's CD I couldn't eject my USB stick and our problem is probably 
related to the way  "this automagic stuff" mounts the volumes. 
Perhaps everybody with some version of Linux has these problems (I tried my 
stick with 2 users under M$, both could write to it). We may call that a bug 
(unless it is an option).

Your problem is much more serious, in the sense that it invalidates the whole 
purpose of the USB stick (file transfer), but it may be simpler to solve 
(just a guess).
The great difference between your case and ours is that you unplugged and 
replugged the stick... the person on the 2nd machine should then become the 
owner of the stick, so something else must be locking your files.
I would first check if the problem doesn't come from the permissions of the 
folders and files inside the device. Try it on M$ perhaps. Don't give up too 
soon.

cheers		Perry

-- 
BOFH excuse #5: static from plastic slide rules



More information about the kubuntu-users mailing list