Proposal for resolving powernowd/apmd vs. (k)powersave conflict

Luka Renko 74.luka at gmail.com
Tue Mar 14 23:43:57 GMT 2006


I have just published current situation and rough plan of further
steps on Ubuntu Wiki:
https://wiki.ubuntu.com/KubuntuPowersave

Please comment and add as you feel appropriate.

Regards,
Luka

On 3/10/06, Michael Biebl <biebl at teco.edu> wrote:
> Luka Renko wrote:
> > Hello,
>
> Hi,
>
> I promised last weekend that I would provide (k)powersave packages for
> testing. Unfortunately I was sick the last few days and was unable to do
> any work. Today I finally managed to prepare packages which I would like
> you to test. More on that later.
>
> > I am still looking how to make usable powersaved/kpowersave packages that
> > would not clash with kubuntu-desktop (and hopefully also ubuntu-desktop
> and
> > edubuntu-desktop). As you may know, the main problem is that powernowd and
> > apmd packages are not compatible with powersaved (as they do the same
> stuff
> > and there are known issues if both run at the same time). Debian
> powersaved
> > package has a rule to remove apmd and powernowd, which then also removes
> > *-desktop packages. :-(
> >
> > I would suggest the following workaround for this "catch22" problem:
> >
> > 1. Get rid of "Conflicts: powernowd apmd" rule
> > This will allow powersaved/kpowersave to be installed on Kubuntu
> (including
> > the case where ubuntu/edubuntu-desktop is there). As this can lead to
> known
> > issues, we will also...
> >
> > 2. Change "/etc/init.d/powersaved start" to stop powernowd/apmd before
> > starting powersaved
> > Start should just call "stop" methods of powernowd/apmd rc scripts. Good
> > thing is that powersaved is started after powernowd and ampd:
> > /etc/rc3.d/S20apmd
> > /etc/rc3.d/S20powernowd
> > /etc/rc3.d/S25powersaved
>
> This approach has many problems and I would advise strongly against it.
>
> 1.) It's a waste of resources. Having installed different cpufrequency
> daemons while only one can be run at a time makes no sense (That's why I
> added the Conflicts).
> 2.) Slowes down boot process. You have to start apmd and powernowd
> first, and kill it later. And we all want a fast boot ;-)
> 3.) It's not transparent for the user: If a user sees powernowd start
> during boot and later sees no powernowd process running he might think
> that the process has crashed or something alike.
> 4.) Problems on package upgrades of powernowd/apmd. Imagine a package
> upgrade of powernowd/apmd where the init script is called in the
> postinst maintainer script. You would again have conflicting processes
> running at the same time.
>
> Given all this reasons, this approach seems not viable too me. Besides
> this hack is not needed at all ;-)
> If kubuntu decides to go with (k)powersave, kubuntu-desktop would simply
> depend on kpowersave/powersaved instead of apmd/powernowd/klaptopdaemon.
> Problem solved.
> For now, to give you a chance to easily test my packages I added a
> Conflicts/Replaces/Provides: powernowd, apmd to powersaved and a
> Conflicts/Replaces/Provides: klaptopdaemon to kpowersave.
> This way kubuntu-desktop is not unistalled if you "apt-get install
> kpowersave".
>
> The more important problem is, how we handle the event processing done
> by acpid. Right now, acpi-support installs a bunch of scripts in
> /etc/acpi/. When an acpi event happens (e.g. a power button pressed
> event), acpid calls the script defined in /etc/acpi/events/powerbtn
> (/etc/acpi/powerbtn.sh). This is obviously not what we want, because
> powersaved should be responsible for all event processing and apply the
> correct rules and policies. acpid's sole purpose is to provide a socket
> where several processes (powersaved, hald, Xorg) can listen on acpid events.
>
> So we have three possibilities here (in decreasing order of my preference):
> 1.) Install a diversion of /usr/sbin/acpid. Create a wrapper script for
> acpid and filter the arguments passed to acpid. When acpid is called
> with -c /etc/acpi/events replace it with -c /etc/acpi/event.ignore (an
> empty directory installed by powersaved). This effectively and
> efficiently disables the event processing of acpid. This is the approach
> I have taken right now. Take a look at /usr/sbin/acpid after installing
> powersaved.
> I first tried to divert the /etc/init.d/acpid init script but this
> failed because dpkg's config file handling comes into play at that moment.
> 2.) Add a
> if pidof powersaved; then
>     exit 0
> fi
> stanza at the beginning of each script in /etc/acpi. This means we would
> have to prepare new releases for acpid and acpi-support. In addition it
> would be less efficient, because acpid would starts a shell for each
> event to process and simply quits directly afterwards.
> 3.) Provide a modified version of the acpid package for kubuntu (IIRC
> this is not possible) which includes a modified init script.
>
> I strongly prefer the first option.
> I prepared packages and uploaded it to my private repo.
> Add the following to /etc/apt/sources.list
>
> deb http://www.teco.edu/~biebl/ubuntu/ dapper main
> deb-src http://www.teco.edu/~biebl/ubuntu/ dapper main
>
> My repository is signed with my GPG key. You can find instructions how
> to use it at [1].
> Please test these packages and report any problems.
>
> @Jonathan: Is there a realistic chance that these packages make it into
> Dapper or is too late for the feature freeze?
> @Achim,Luka: Please start the procedure to get these packages into the
> Dapper archive. I'm not familiar with the (K)ubuntu procedures so I
> wanted to pass this task on to you or at least give me assistance. IIRC
> Jonathan talked about a laptop testing group in ubuntu where we should
> send these packages too, how would we do that.
>
> Let's get as much testing quickly as possible and then Jonathan can
> decide if (k)powersave should be used as the default power management
> solution for Kubuntu 6.04
>
> Regards,
> Michael
>
> [1] http://www.teco.edu/~biebl/ubuntu/
> --
> Why is it that all of the instruments seeking intelligent life in the
> universe are pointed away from Earth?
>
>
>



More information about the kubuntu-devel mailing list