[PATCH 0/2] [lucid] LP#538377 -- Radeon HDMI output turns off randomly
chase.douglas at canonical.com
Thu Apr 8 19:11:42 UTC 2010
On Thu, Apr 8, 2010 at 8:13 AM, Andy Whitcroft <apw at canonical.com> wrote:
> This seems to be triggered by PLL setup issues. There is a somewhat
> larger than I would like rewrite of this whole algorithm in mainline.
> This seems to fix the issue for the reporters.
> I think we want this for Lucid, but it is rather large. Comments?
I'm concerned by the size of the patches as well. It sets a new
default algo for avivo cards. I think we should put the patches in,
but add a third UBUNTU SAUCE patch that reverts the default to the
legacy pll algo (by initializing radeon_new_pll to 0 instead of -1).
Since the bug symptoms are that the display works for a while and then
all of a sudden turns off, this should at least allow people to still
boot. In the release notes we can note that there's a new pll algo
that can be enabled by adding the following to
options radeon new_pll=1
Or perhaps we ship it with it commented out so people can more easily enable it?
There's also another pll patch that fixes some LCD issues , but it
touches both the new and legacy algos, so I'd be afraid to apply it
without good reason.
So, with a reverted default I would say Ack to both patches. But
without, I'd say Nack to both.
More information about the kernel-team