[Bug 441195] Re: [karmic][lucid] Intel HDA 82801G (ICH7) | STAC9200 - Mixer controlling wrong settings

[Tristan Schmelcher]

@Daniel et al.

This is not a driver bug. I investigated the driver and hardware a lot
and discussed the issue in an ALSA bug report: https://bugtrack.alsa-
project.org/alsa-bug/view.php?id=5031  As you can see in my last
comment, I have requested that my "bug" report be closed, because I
decided that ALSA is working correctly.

The STAC 92xx chipset has two hardware volume controls, one for the L/R
channel and one for the subwoofer (LFE) that is derived from L+R. But
neither hardware volume affects the other. The so-called "Master" only
affects the stereo internal speakers. It has no effect on the LFE
volume. That's just how the chip is designed. :(

The job of ALSA kernel drivers is to present an interface to what the
hardware implements, so it is doing the right thing. AFAIK there is no
social contract in ALSA that a hardware volume control named "Master" is
multiplied with all others. If there were then it would be a design
flaw, because there is nothing to stop chipset developers from making a
product that is incompatible with that, as we are seeing here. It is not
reasonable for the Linux kernel to attempt to provide functionality that
does not exist in the hardware.

To fix this issue, PulseAudio needs to either change the LFE volume in
sync with the Master volume or use the PCM softvol exclusively, which is
the work-around that I have adopted by adding "load-module module-alsa-
sink control=PCM" to default.pa. The PCM approach is sub-optimal though
because a software volume presumably incurs quantization error at low
volume levels.

See also the upstream bug at http://pulseaudio.org/ticket/457

I do agree though that it would be nearly impossible to work around this
in PulseAudio and have it work for all hardware. I think the best
solution would be for PA to have a blacklist of chipsets with dumb
volume control designs and simply use the PCM control for them
exclusively.

** Bug watch added: ALSA Bug Tracker #5031
   https://bugtrack.alsa-project.org/alsa-bug/view.php?id=5031

-- 
[karmic][lucid] Intel HDA 82801G (ICH7) | STAC9200 - Mixer controlling wrong settings
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/441195
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Kernel
Bugs, which is subscribed to linux in ubuntu.