[Bug 301353] Re: HP Pavilion dv5: ATA exception on resume from suspend

[wollombi]

Well, that's unfortunate.  I had hoped it would be the fix we're all
waiting for.  I'm about to throw my beloved lappy out the window.

Don't get me wrong, I love my laptop, and I love linux, but I'm about to
the point where I'd give my left nut for a real, working suspend.

On another note, I tried the same version of Ubuntu (8.10) on my Asus
(F3Sv) laptop. It ran fine, suspend and all on 8.04 but guess what?
Doesn't seem to be working on 8.10.  This is with a different
processor/chipset than the DV5.  I'm going to do a clean install when I
next have a few minutes to burn and see if the problem persists.  Right
now it's using the old drive from my DV5, so that may be skewing things.
If it works then, it may be worth checking out the differences in the
SATA controller between the two chipsets.  If it doesn't, then it will
still be worth seeing why it worked with 8.04 but not with 8.10.
Honestly I would have stuck w/8.04 on the DV5 if it had supported the
intel wireless properly, but compiling the updated kernel into 8.04 gave
me some weirdness I didn't like (my first kernel compile so I may have
inadvertantly caused that myself).  I'll update when I have more info.
Until then the relevant specs on the Asus below:

Asus F3Sv

Core 2 Duo T7500 (2.20 GHz), 800MHz FSB, 4MB L2 cache
PM965 chipset (Santa Rosa)
3 GB DDR2-667 RAM
nVidia 8600M GS graphics 
160GB 5400rpm SATA HDD (came with Hitachi, currently has the DV5's WD in it - same size and speed)


Sean

-- 
HP Pavilion dv5: ATA exception on resume from suspend
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/301353
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Kernel
Bugs, which is subscribed to Linux.