dots in charm names (shelr.tv)

[William Reade]

On Tue, 2013-03-26 at 15:35 +0100, Abel Deuring wrote:
> On 26.03.2013 13:51, Gustavo Niemeyer wrote:
> > Shouldn't the charm world be talking to the store to see if the charm
> > actually exists?  Otherwise we'll end up with that situation where we
> > have two separate worlds with slightly diverging opinions.
> 
> well, we retrieve the data about charms from Launchpad. My question was
> simply: Is it worth to change charmworld so that it can properly deal
> with the name shelr.tv, or should the name be fixed because it might
> also be unusable in juju-core?

Gustavo's point is that the charm store is the canonical data source for
juju; and so, it *should* also be for charmworld. The may very well be
contention wrt whether this is a feasible change to make right now; but
I don't see any grounds to disagree re "should". Am I missing something?

> As I understand William, shelr.tv would be rejected by juju-core, so I
> am inclined to say that the name should be changed.

Agreed.

Cheers
William