[Bug 1025395] Re: Setup creates non-optimal disk layout for disks with 4kb sectors

[Dave Gilbert]

Triaged: Full install instructions given, and explanation of what's broken
High: A problem with an essential hardware component (80MB->18MB is enough for me to say that's not just a minor perf)

Dave

** Changed in: debian-installer (Ubuntu)
   Importance: Undecided => High

** Changed in: debian-installer (Ubuntu)
       Status: Confirmed => Triaged

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Foundations Bugs, which is subscribed to debian-installer in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1025395

Title:
  Setup creates non-optimal disk layout for disks with 4kb sectors

Status in “debian-installer” package in Ubuntu:
  Triaged

Bug description:
  Hard disks are sold with 4kb sectors nowadays. Nevertheless, they
  masquerade themselves as 512 byte sectored disks to the operating
  system for backwards compatibility. This allows non-optimal sector
  alignment if partitions do not start on the proper boundary.

  Ubuntu setup will create such unoptimal partitions.
  The result is that the RAID5 resync performance of the affected machine was 18 MB/s for me. This is VERY poor performance: After I created the partitions manually with proper alignment before Ubuntu setup, the machine does 80 MB/s.

  Because I document all machines I setup, I can give you 100% precise
  instructions of reproducing this:

  - Netboot install using PXE, Ubuntu 11.10 image obtained from http://archive.ubuntu.com/ubuntu/dists/precise/main/installer-amd64/current/images/netboot/netboot.tar.gz
  - md5sum of image is ad0d0feb7c31b520151b95242463f990 
  - Boot the machine via PXE, select "Install" from PXE menu. What follows are the exact selections during setup:

  - Select a language: English
  - Select your location: Other / Europe / Germany
  - Configure locales: United States - en_US.UTF-8
  - Configure the keyboard: Detect keyboard layout => Yes => de:nodeadkeys
  - Configure the network - Primary network interface: eth0 (onboard, 82579V), DHCP worked
  - Configure the network - Hostname: server
  - Choose a mirror of the Ubuntu archive: mirror country - Germany, mirror - de.archive.ubuntu.com, proxy - <empty>
  - Setup users and passwords: Full name / user name for new user: benjamin, encrypt home directory: no
  - Configure the clock - timezone: Europe/Berlin
  - Partition disks - manual:

  	We have 3x 3TB disks with 4KB sectors.
  		sda:
  			new partition table: yes
  			parititions sorted by position on disk:
  				partition 1 - 1073741824 B (= 1GB, specified byte-size to guarantee proper sector alignment), Name: <empty>, Use as: Reserved BIOS boot area, Bootable flag: off
  				partition 2 - 4294967296 B (= 4GB, specified byte-size to guarantee proper sector alignment). Name: <empty>, Use as: Physical Volume for raid, Bootable flag: off
  				partition 3 - specify "max" as size to use the remaining space, Name: <empty>, Use as: Physical Volume for raid, Bootable flag: off

  		sdb:
  			new partition table: yes
  			parititions sorted by position on disk:
  				partition 1 - 1073741824 B (= 1GB, specified byte-size to guarantee proper sector alignment), Name: <empty>, Use as: Reserved BIOS boot area, Bootable flag: off
  				partition 2 - 4294967296 B (= 4GB, specified byte-size to guarantee proper sector alignment). Name: <empty>, Use as: Physical Volume for raid, Bootable flag: off
  				partition 3 - specify "max" as size to use the remaining space, Name: <empty>, Use as: Physical Volume for raid, Bootable flag: off

  		sdc:
  			new partition table: yes
  			parititions sorted by position on disk:
  				partition 1 - 1073741824 B (= 1GB, specified byte-size to guarantee proper sector alignment), Name: <empty>, Use as: Reserved BIOS boot area, Bootable flag: off
  				partition 2 - 4294967296 B (= 4GB, specified byte-size to guarantee proper sector alignment). Name: <empty>, Use as: Physical Volume for raid, Bootable flag: off
  				partition 3 - specify "max" as size to use the remaining space, Name: <empty>, Use as: Physical Volume for raid, Bootable flag: off

  		select "Configure software RAID":
  			Create MD device - RAID1, active devices: 3, spare devices: 0, using the 4GB disks: sda2, sdb2, sdc2
  			Create MD device - RAID5, active devices: 3, spare devices: 0, using the 3TB disks: sda3, sdb3, sdc3

  	back to partitioning menu, now configure the raid devices' usage:
  		under "RAID1 device #0 (4GB)" select part "#1 4.0GB":
  				use as: ext3, mount point: /boot, mount options: noatime, label: boot, reserved block: 5%, typical usage: standard

  		RAID5 device #1, configure "#1 6.0TB":
  				use as: physical volume for encryption,
  				
  				encryption parameters - leave those at default if you are no mathematician: 
  					encryption method: device-mapper (dm-crypt), encryption: aes, key size: 256, iv algorithm: cbc-essiv:sha256, encryption key: passphrase, erasa data: NO if disks were randomized before, YES otherwise

  	select "Configure encrypted volumes:"
  			select "Create encrypted volumes" - devices to encrypt: /dev/md1
  			now select "Finish" and enter the passphrase when asked

  
  	back to the partitioning menu again:
  		Now notice the follwing bug in the partitioner: the ext3 raid device for "/boot" is NOT marked as being used for "/boot" anymore!
  		- correct its parameters, now you must also set "Format the partition: yes" because it was formated before when we first configured it and we want it to be clean.

  		under "Enccrypted volume (md1_crypt)" select part "#1 6.0TB":
  			use as: xfs, mount point: /, mount options: noatime, label: root

  		- finish partitioning and write changes to disk.
  		- boot the system when the raid becomes degraded: yes.
  		- return to the partitioning menu to create swap: no.
  		- write changes to disk: yes.

  - Configure discover: Install security updates automatically
  - Software selection: Basic Ubuntu server, Samba file server
  - Install GRUB onto master boot record: Yes.
  - Is the system clock set to UTC? Yes.
  - Installation is complete. Continue :)

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/debian-installer/+bug/1025395/+subscriptions