VCS comparison table
aaron.bentley at utoronto.ca
Tue Oct 17 20:44:37 BST 2006
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Andreas Ericsson wrote:
>> In Bazaar, a revision id always refers to the same logical entity, but
>> it may be stored in different formats in different repositories.
> This I don't understand. Let's say Alice has revision-154 in her repo,
> located at alice.example.com. Let's say that commit is accessible with
> the url "alice.example.com:revision-154". Bob pulls from her repo into
> his own, which is located at bob.example.com.
> Lots of questions here, so I'll split them up. Feel free to delete the
> non-applicable ones.
> Will the commit in Bob's repo be accessible at
bzr differentiates between pull and merge. Pull is a mirroring command.
So with pull, yes revision-154 will be accessible at
With merge, it won't. Bob can refer to it as "154:alice.example.com",
> If it's not, how can you backtrack from old bugreports and find the
> error being discussed?
Refer to it as 'alice.example.com revno 154' or by its revision-id.
> If it is, how does that work if Bob suddenly wants to commit things
> before Alice is done working with her changes?
I don't see how this applies. You can always commit in a branch. If
alice and bob both commit, then they are diverged and can't pull. If
alice merges bob, then they converge and bob can pull alice.
> Also, suppose they both push to a master-repo where Caesar has pushed
> his changes and nicked the slot for revision-154. Does the master repo
> re-organize everything and then invalidate Bob's and Alice's changes, or
> does it tell Alice and Bob that they need to update and then reorganize
> their repos before they're allowed to push?
They must merge from the master-repo before they can push to it.
>> In our terminology, if it can diverge from the original, it's a branch,
>> not a checkout.
> This clears things up immensely. bazaar checkout != git checkout.
> I still fail to see how a local copy you can't commit to is useful
My bzr is run from a local copy I can't commit to. To get the latest
changes from http://bazaar-vcs.org, I can run "bzr update ~/bzr/dev".
To merge the latest changes into my branch, I can run
"bzr merge ~/bzr/dev". It's also convenient for applying other peoples'
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://enigmail.mozdev.org
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the bazaar